I've had a Creative Soundblaster X-Fi Xtreme Music sound card (whew!) for the last fourteen months or so. And I'm at a point where I'm considering getting rid of it, but I'm kind of torn.
The problem is, the card cannot connect to the front panel audio. There are times when I am running a dishwasher load or washing some clothes late at night when I'd like to be able to slap on some headphones so I don't blow the ears off of everyone else in my apartment complex. But Creative wants you to buy the more expensive Platinum X-Fi card, which is the same card but includes their own proprietary front panel port that fits into a 3.5" drive bay (mine is occupied by my FDD, so I'd have to purchase a 5.25"-3.5" converter bay for my case as well). There is also a way to create an adapter that will allow you to connect the ports (Velocity Micro has their own adapter for Creative cards that allows them to connect to the front panel), but it would be a major pain in the ass to make.
The other thing is that when it comes to sound quality, I honest to goodness just cannot tell a difference. I was playing the demo for Clive Barker's Jericho tonight (which btw is fucking awesome), and I thought the sound was incredible just with the onboard HD audio. The Creative cards support EAX, which is a kind of positional sound processing that's supposed to make distant sounds sound more realistic. But I actually thought they sounded less realistic; for example, in F.E.A.R., if you walk around a corner and a grenade goes off, you hear a muffled "ffmmmm" instead of a loud "bang!". Even though the grenade is right there, the game is treating it like you're in another room. Kinda lame. There are also some EQ features with the Creative card that supposedly optimize the sound for gaming, audio creation and music, but honestly switching between the various modes is more hassle than it's worth.
So I'm a little torn. It's not a bad card, and it's kinda cool to have especially since it was a gift, but I don't want to go through the trouble of making my own front panel plug/wire for the card especially since I could permanently damage the front panel audio wire. Frankly the card's features and software package are not a big deal. Creative installs a bunch of resource-hungry services that I'm not a fan of, although if I owned a Creative MP3 player I would be into it (I own an iPod).
Oh, and what set this all off is that currently, my motherboard will not boot when the sound card is installed. Weird eh? Just another hassle that makes me wonder if I really want the card.



